May 18, 2011

when the milking goes bad, or, the honeymoon is over

Here's a little-known insight for those of you who have never milked a cow, but would like to try it. The milk? is not supposed to go on the ground.


You're welcome.

The thing is, Banjo is a ballerina. Didn't think a heifer could dance? Well, you've never met Banjo. This girl can spin on a dime. To contain her we built a stanchion, which is too wide and not only fails to keep her restrained but actually makes it harder to milk by putting up a block at eye level. The milking machine, which is hella heavy, seems like it should sit at her feet, but that's just begging for disaster, so instead we hang it from a strap slung over her back, where it swings with her every movement, and threatens to spill over, so we have to balance that with one hand while holding the suckers on her teats with the other four hands we've magically sprouted. All of this is much harder on us than it is on her, trust me. But occasionally she gets irritable -- specifically if her treats run out and we're still milking -- so she starts dancing forward and back, side to side, the machine swinging with her, while we desperately follow it from a crouched position from which we're delivering a signed invitation to have our feet smashed by her gigantic feet and our faces bashed in by her enormous flank.

Surprisingly, this doesn't always work out so well. Sometimes the suckers come loose and we have to pull off the machine until suction builds again. Sometimes she outright kicks us off, gouging our hands in the process. And sometimes, albeit rarely, the machine flies off the strap and tips over entirely, milk either spilling out onto the floor or backflowing into the suction tubes.

In such an event all we can say is, You win, Banjo.


This farm is only a year in the making, and so much infrastructure is not yet in place. Like a functional milking stanchion. Or a chicken coop that isn't sinking into an eroding hillside. Or an isolation area for new chicks. Or a garden of raised beds. Or fences that actually do their job. Sometimes I look around and all I see are problems, mistakes, disasters in the making (or already made and not yet repaired). Most of the time, I feel paralyzed, incapable of making positive decisions to take corrective or preventive action -- I just go through the motions of milking-feeding-tending and try not to look too closely at the fences or the garden or the coop.

And I'll admit, I've been poised to throw in the towel. I've been exhausted far past the limit of my capabilities and considered how nice it would be to work on a developed farm that's already been carefully managed for several years by highly experienced labor. Or maybe I should go back to renting and just resign myself to the organic section of the supermarket. For now, the benefits side of this equation is outweighing the costs, but I can't promise those scales won't tip. Sometimes I have to sit down and consciously remind myself of the math so I don't go running screaming out to the highway.

Cue gratuitous chick-pic:


Okay, it's still worth it.

15 comments:

A Girl In An Apron said...

Your photos are so incredible! Keep your chin up! The organic section of the grocery store is still no comparison. . . thanks for the post!

killing Mother said...

I have sympathetic lower back pain for you. Just keep reminding yourself - a day on the farm will always be better than a work day almost anywhere else. It gets easier.

K2tog said...

We raise dairy goats and have had similar "milk behavioral" problems with one of our does try milking by hand for awhile and creep feeding while on the stand. They start to see milk time as a kind of treat. We have been homesteading for 12 years and trust me - there is always something waiting to get done... and it is always worth it.

Methylgrace said...

Why in heaven's name did you have your camera handy while spilling milk? And how the heck did you get such a clear shot? Sheesh.

When we moved into our Seattle home 5 years ago, ... after all of the house renovations (another story) ... we removed 9 of 11 sheds on the property (ants, termites, rot and seriously? 11 sheds on 1/5th of an acre?), moved one of those sheds from the front yard to the back. Then I built two wooden fences to keep the little kids from running into the street, reoriented the vegetable beds, built a free-cycled greenhouse (with no instructions, or help from hubby, grr).

So only now am I building the chicken coop and doubling the vegetable bed space. Try to keep the big picture in mind and just tackle one project at a time.

Hang in there!

Zonnah said...

I understand the overwhelming feeling! Take it one step at a time :)

Lucy said...

Is this a bad time to invite you to my recently inherited 170 acres in NH (with ten acres of hay and pasture!)? I need someone who knows what they are doing.....

amypayson said...

My fave part...the gratuitous chick pic. LOL.

donna rae said...

What a great post! Don't we all have those moments of "What am I DOING?"? Glad you decided to go with the 'benefits side of the equation'!

Nature Creek Farm said...

Milking suggestions:
1. The surge bucket milker should not be "sitting at her feet", it should be hanging on a strap over her back. This weight also acts to calm her down. (it's called a "surcingle" strap, I think).
2. When milking, get close. It's a prize fight and you have to control her by crowding her and being part of her, just like the calf. Put your head deep into her side, between the bulge of the stomach and her hind leg. She will still kick and lift the leg, but not as high or fast.

Chandelle said...

Thanks, NCF. It might not have been clear in the post, but we do put the Surge on a strap over her back, not at her feet -- I meant that I wish we could put it at her feet because the strap situation is so precarious with it constantly threatening to tip off.

I definitely notice a positive difference when I'm very close to her during milking. As mentioned, though, the stanchion puts up a block and makes things much more difficult. The stanchion needs improvement or to be removed altogether. Just one of the major infrastructure lapses in this place.

Lucy, congrats on the land! What an amazing inheritance. But don't tempt me out there because I'd blow it sky-high. I'm definitely not in the category of people who know what they're doing... quite the opposite. :)

Thanks for the encouragement, everyone! This was a hard week but it's getting better. Methylgrace, you should get a medal for your efforts... I feel humbled with my small projects here. (And I had the camera handy because I was headed outside after milking. :)

outlawfarmer said...

Hi Chandelle,

First off I have to say your blog is the bomb! You put into words so many layers of your experiences. I find myself laughing and crying and saying things out loud like "Holy crap, me too!"

I have some tips for you to consider for your farming projects but I'm by no means an expert.

1. Chicken tractors work great for me and they are relatively inexpensive to make AND you can use them to prepare garden beds. The ones I made can be moved with one hand. I move them every day so the chickens always have fresh grass.

2. I also use a hobble for a couple of my "special" goats. I have found if a goat is difficult to milk the first year, she's that way her whole life. But that's just my experience. Anyway the word hobble sounds horrible but the kind I use is just a vinyl strap that goes around the back legs and Velcros into place. BTW, it is designed for cows and it keeps them from being able to dance around on the stand. It costs about $15 I think.

3. When you do get around to making your raised beds, wet newspaper provides a great barrier to the grass and weeds. It is also great to mulch with after your plants are large enough. I use it in thick layers and then pile on spent hay from the barn. It really keeps the weeds down and the soil from drying out. Plus earthworms love newspaper for some reason.

I'm almost through here I promise. But I also wanted to mention I struggle with feeling overwhelmed and discouraged. But then like you when I reflect on the richness of this crazy life I'm living, the imperfections seem to add another layer to the whole point, which for me is discovering a sustainable way to inhabit this planet and tap into the realness of the dirt.

Thanks for such a great blog. I enjoy reading your thoughts so much.

Chandelle said...

Thanks, outlawfarmer. Your blog is one of my favorites as well.

Chicken tractors are not a good option here because the land is very cobbled and hilly. I wish they were because they're such a great concept, but right now the chickens just range as far as they like on the hills.

I think the lady did just buy some sort of clamp that goes over the back legs to stop kicking. I assume that will help, but honestly kicking is not that much of a problem. The greater issue is that she moves side to side and front to back as much as she likes. That causes real problems with the milking machine. This weekend I'm hoping to fix the stanchion so she's a bit more confined.

Half of the beds are done but thanks for the tip on the newspaper so I can try that with the other half!

(It looks like a comment from mpocket didn't show up? Hm...)

Quimby said...

I debated leaving this comment for two days, because I know that your automatic assumption, when you see my name, is to take it as a personal attack. But what you are doing to that poor cow is bordering on abuse. A jersey is a small, gentle, tender cow. Of course she is going to react poorly to having a contraption like a milking machine put on her back! Think of the weight this puts on her back. Think of the uncomfortable vibrations. Once upon a time you would've accused me of animal abuse for hitting a cow with the palm of my hand to get it to move away from me. And now you are strapping a heavy, uncomfortable machine on the back of a small jersey, and you think this is acceptable? She is not comfortable during milking. It is your task to make her comfortable. This can be done much easier with comforting words and a bit of grain, than with a heavy, vibrating machine strapped on her back. Cows are not meant to be beasts of burdens - especially not dairy cows, especially not jerseys. I have been around dairy cows for 15 years now. What you are doing is counter-productive. Poor Banjo. Of course she isn't liking milking time! PS - If you think this is harsh, be grateful I am not getting my father-in-law, with his 70 years of milking experience, to comment.

Quimby said...

According to my husband - who has been milking since he was 10 - you should not be having to hold the cups on when you are milking. If you are having to do that, you should get someone to look at the machine because there is something wrong with the suction. You should only be having to attach the cups, then talk to the cow, pet her, feed her some grain, interact with her; in 10 to 15 minutes she'll be milked; you can take the cups off, and you can both get on with your day. If you are having to hold the cups on, you may as well be milking by hand.

Chandelle said...

Q, I share your upset about the machine. Personally, I despise using the machine and would be much happier milking by hand if I had the choice. But I don't. I'm following directions here and some of those directions don't make sense to me or are contradictory to my instincts and yet, to do my job I have to follow them. And this is not only related to the milking -- there's quite a lot happening here that makes me uncomfortable and I'm not sure how to navigate it right now.

I will say that the machine doesn't actually seem to bother Banjo very much. She only moves around impatiently if she finishes her food before the milking is done. It's rare that she tries to kick it off. The machine doesn't really vibrate. I am very unhappy about the strap across her back but other milkers assure me this is how it's supposed to be, that I'm projecting because I can't conceive of how heavy she really is. I don't know enough to know if that's true or not.

As for the cups slipping off, that makes no sense to me, either. I don't know why the suction is off like that -- she bought the machine used and doesn't seem too concerned about the suction.

So to answer your objections, no, it's not acceptable to me, and yes, I do consider it my first task to make her comfortable. I'm trying to figure out how to manage the fact that this doesn't seem to be the first priority overall on this farm. Over the past week I've begun to consider that I might not be able to stay here if I'm not able to approach the animals this way.