thoughts from 3:00 am

For two years, my family has been living in a 300-square-foot, one-room living space. This has been a challenge on many, many levels. 


When we first moved to this cabin, we didn't have a refrigerator. For most of the summer, we stored our fresh food in a cooler on our back deck, piled with ice that we replenished daily. We finally acquired a propane fridge, significantly smaller than any refrigerator we've ever had.

For several months we had sketchy hot water. Sometimes it worked, sometimes it did not work and we had no idea why. We took a great many cold showers, and some showers so hot we contorted our bodies to avoid the spray.


We live off-road and for many weeks at a time, during the rainy season, we've driven a 4WD vehicle on and off the ranch, transferring our things to and from our usual small car once we hit the paved road.

We have no neighbors and we live 25 minutes from town, 30 minutes from work, and more than an hour from anything that could be called a city. Some days we spend more than two hours in the car. 

My partner and I have not had privacy from our children for two years. 

 

We have never had cell phone reception or Internet access in this cabin. We wash our clothes in a laundromat each week. Needless to say, we don't have a dishwasher or microwave.

Before we had solar panels, we were dependent on a generator to have electric lights, which entailed a ear-shattering, gas-guzzling beast on our back deck. With solar panels, we can run lights, charge our laptop, and run a low-power blender, but not much else.


We have not hung a photograph or piece of art for two years, owing to the steep cant of our walls. For every thing that has entered our home, some other thing has left. We restrict our consumption of clothing, toys, books, kitchen implements, toiletries, furniture, craft supplies, and hobby materials according to the natural limits placed by our tiny home. 

If I came upon some thing that I desired, most of the time I could not have it, because we didn't have enough space for it or enough energy to run it.


I regret none of this. At the end of my days, I expect to look back on this experiment in living as one of the happiest times in my life. My family has grown closer, and we've all grown stronger and more resilient. I've learned so much about what qualifies as “standard of living” and how to define this standard for myself. I know what I need to feel comfortable and what I appreciate simply because it makes my life easier. 

I have a clear understanding of which luxuries have been inflated to necessities by a culture that elevates consumption to the status of a virtue. I understand that living with less, far from being constricting, exhausting, frustrating, or otherwise limiting, can be liberating and ultimately bring about greater contentment – even if you occasionally want to kick the on-demand water heater.

None of this means that I think you should go live in a cabin in the woods. This is only what I've found for myself.


My parents raised me to be deeply distrustful of welfare systems and disdainful of anyone who utilized those programs. I still flush with shame when I remember the years I spent on food stamps, and the times my family has been dependent on family assistance to pay our bills are branded in my mind with deep regret. 

On a fundamental level, I believe in living within your means, but our “means” have historically been out-of-sync with basic expenses like rent and food, even though we've rarely been without work. It was during those times that we became dependent on family and governmental help. And even though our income is higher than it's ever been, we still lack basic healthcare, such that I recently had to take outside work – on top of my full-time job – to acquire the funds necessary for a doctor visit.  


We might be detached from the grid, but our children have healthcare through California's “gap” program for low-income kids – and thank goodness for it. Because we produce our own water and energy and much of our food, we're less dependent on “the system” than most people, but in other ways we are more dependent than ever – with no end in sight. 

This might be the most important lesson I've learned out here in the boonies. I feel a tug when I consider the many, many ways that we cannot provide for ourselves. We still buy food in a grocery store. We still drive a car (a shitload, too). We use propane. We are helpless. We are culpable. 

 

When you start thinking about Transition -- about walkable cities, asset-based community development, sustainable food production, green energy, re-skilling, and so forth -- you begin to realize that we are at an absolute disadvantage to our government. When I consider my level of consciousness from several years ago, I realize that I was so pampered and provided-for by my government that I was functionally willing to exchange the health of entire ecosystems for a washing machine and dishwasher. This might have even seemed like a fair trade. 

But even with a raised consciousness I've been humbled by our limitations at every turn.

 

I've learned so much from living in this place, from doing this work. But a few days ago I happened on this old post from Cinnamon Girl and when I read the following line, I thought, Well damn. That's our situation in a nutshell.  
"There comes a point for me when trying to accomplish something where I depart from the land of trying oh so hard and move into a space where things are very clearly being forced."
That's where I am, and it sucks. Because it leads to questions like this, questions that float through the miasma of a cold night when you're lying in bed in your one-room, off-grid, off-road cabin, insulated with earth and recycled fibers and fueled by solar panels, pondering your impending move to a “regular” house and subsequent inevitable connection to the grid: are we going to be re-assimilated? Are we going to become numbed and lulled by thoughtless water and energy acquisition and abandon what we've learned? In the thrill of access to streaming Netflix, will we forget what kind of world we want to live in? 

I think that would be a shame. It's just not possible for us to continue having all this crap indefinitely, maybe not even for much longer. I, for one, want to understand how unnecessary it is – that a joyful life is possible without these tethers. 

 

7 comments:

Terri Schanks said...

Thanks for your honest comments. I think many of us struggle with what "balance" means in this time. I work from home and have an organic yard in the middle of the city, but still drive a big ol CRV everywhere. I grow and can a lot of food and buy a lot from local sources, but still eat out a lot. I am totally on-grid, although I use a lot less than others. But when all is said and done, at least for me, it's about being in touch with my own values, which include gentleness, acceptance and a sense of peace. And that has to start with me first. It has to start with listening to my heart above all other voices and in all things exercising moderation...including moderation. Sometimes chocolate is good for my soul. Sometimes a movie is about living a full life. Sometimes being on grid means I'm actually using less than I would living off grid. Sometimes just being okay with it not totally being perfect is the most kind, loving thing I can do for myself and therefore for the earth and all other beings around me.
What I really respect about you and the way you share your journey is that you can let go of it needing to look a certain way and instead give into what it could look like without the projections. Sort of like the veg/meat debate, I think on-grid/off-grid can be as rigid sometimes.
What I think I know today is that a true encounter with that wise part of us will always liberate something in us that is akin to hope and resilience and an ability to bounce back when we thought we were totally defeated. There is a certain alchemy in times like this, that power of creative transformation, that will always lead you to the next level.
I'm sure whatever you are guided to do will be a success and bring wonderful new surprises.
Be gentle with you and your journey. Oh, and if I may give a piece of unsolicited feedback?
It's so ok to allow yourself the comforts of home and netflix. You haven't failed in that. You don't have to prove yourself to anyone. Even you.
Best wishes on your transitions, wherever they may lead.
Peace :)

mckenzie said...

Chandelle, this was such a necessary thing for me to read tonight. I've been giving a lot of thought to our current living situation these days, for reasons I haven't discussed on my blog. We went from the tiny cabin (which still had more amenities than yours) to a bigger house with a dishwasher and washer/dryer that I use because of their presence. It's just easier. I'm not giving myself a hard time about it right now because my life is harder in so many ways than it was living in the cabin, and I can't beat myself up for not intentionally making it EVEN harder, but I do know this is not the sort of home (as lucky as we are to live here) that I want to be in forever. So to read your phrase, "experiment in living," gave me a tang of hope. I love where we are at the moment and I'm so thankful for being here, but I do want to live in a home with at least a little bit more simplicity again someday. Your family should be proud.

reptilegrrl said...

Honestly, the fact that you are even THINKING about these things means you are ahead of the pack. Most people never ever question the luxuries we have available in the US, or whether or not they can manage to not be sucked in by destructive conveniences.

Life is full of compromises. You have to decide what you will compromise and how. For example, I am disabled and for me an automatic dishwasher is a MUST. Without a dishwasher, I wouldn't be able to cook healthy meals with my atypically-sourced natural foods. A lot of things are not musts: dining out, watching television, fancy new clothes.

I do the best I can within my limits, and when I see a way I can do better, I do that. It is the best we can do.


mossgrownstone said...

I hope your move to a regular house doesn't lead you to abandon what you have learned. I have experienced a life very similar to what you describe here and currently we are on grid (although no drinkable water) and I think it is very hard not be re-assimilated. It's just so easy to take conveniences for granted. Living without them makes life harder. They suck you in and everyone's "like yeah it's ok, enjoy it!" sometimes people are even mind-boggled as to why you are resisting. And it's hard to be surrounded by that too. How will we ever get to where we need to be (as a world) when so many people don't seem to even see there's a problem?! And then there's as you say the realities of all the things we still can't provide for ourselves. Great post!

Erin GardenAndGrub said...

Wow, very well said - your words are my thoughts exactly. Every day I cringe with the thought of how dependent I am on others and things (family, government, grocery store, technology..) - and while it's not bad to accept help or to make life easier, it is very easy to fall into the lull dependency, control and general mind-numbing distractions of "modern" living.
Right now, subsisting and resisting is where it's at for us, and we are in the process of attempting to break through our limitations so that one day, just maybe, we will get to that point. But right now, I'm in the same boat as everyone else - just trying to keep a float.
I've followed your blog for a few months now, and I just want to say I admire your family's path and thank you for sharing the realities of your family's "experiment in living."

Deb said...

What's wrong with depending on others? Humans have for thousands of years. We live together, depend on each other, we are all connected. It doesn't have to be a negative.

Chandelle said...

Deb, I'm definitely not talking about rugged individualism here. There is a difference between sharing needs with a local web of community and depending on invisible & distant government bodies. I do believe in communal interdependence. I think it's the loss of communal interdependence that has caused people to lean more heavily on a government with whom they have no personal connection and which might not have their best interests in mind, very different from a community of mutual support. Communal interdependence is empowering. Government dependence is, in my experience, the opposite.